I ended the first year by opening 1 one-year football
league. At the time, I thought the one-year league was a safe choice to better
entice players to play on the new site. In retrospect, that was a mistake as I
should have opened a keeper league.
In year one I established a distinct
commissioner style in FSRU leagues. To explain it, I have to explain fantasy
sports leagues and the problems that exist in many of them:
In lower level leagues sponsored by the major sports sites on the internet, you
know the ones, the $19.99 to $39.99 per team leagues. In those leagues, trades
are not human reviewed by the sponsor site. Trades are simply initiated by the
software. Collusion through team owners owning more than one team in a league,
or friends in a league, is built into the game. In many leagues, he who controls/influences
the most teams: wins.
Private leagues have an entirely different set
of problems. Private leagues have a commissioner just like internet sites.
Problem number one concerns free agents, because the commissioner plays in the
league he either has access to view free agents before they are issued, or even
worse, he is actually issuing them. This is a potentially BIG advantage.
The second problem concerns the trade
process. A vast majority of private leagues play with either of two league trade
controls: Either the playing commissioner has the power to void, or the league
has a trade void vote. i.e. If 6 team owners vote to void the trade, it is not
processed. In a hobby so ripe with competitiveness, and with money on the line,
and with personal relationships almost always built into the leagues- this
rarely works. Although not in all private leagues, influences and outright
cheating plays out in many during the free agency and trading process.
Joe Blow site has made his own problem
in this regard, he plays teams for sale and trades with teams for sale. That is
a no-no in this industry and that has never been done at FSRU. It is difficult
for him to void a bad trade, when he makes them himself. The integrity of his
leagues is always in question when you do that. He overprices teams for sale
just so he can play them, right now, he has 23 teams for sale-FSRU has zero. In
essence, Joe Blow has incorporated the same problems outlined for private
leagues in his online leagues.
And now we come to the potential landmines in
the fairness provided at upper level sites such as FSRU (oh yea, and Joe Blows
website too). We have a different problem- Sales. Like in most other
businesses, fantasy sports league businesses have a variety of different
duties, including: One, Sales, which is tied into advertising; and two, League
Operations, which is tied into commissioner services. To be successful, you
must separate the two duties. Once teams are paid for, once the season and the
game begins, you cannot let the next year sales impact this years decisions.
If you void a trade and a team owner threatens
to leave the league if the trade is not put through- you cannot budge. Keep in
mind that when you put through a trade, sometimes it will upset owners that
thought it should be voided. If you void a trade, you know the traders will
certainly not be happy. The nature of the job simply does not allow you to make
everyone happy.
As the commissioner, you should always fully explain your reason for each
decision, and do what you think is right for the league. I have found upset
team owners will respect you and the integrity of your leagues- and they will
stay regardless of what was said in the heat of the moment, as long as they
know your decisions are impersonal and objective. A team owner cares about what
is right for their team while the commissioner has a different agenda. He has
to care about what is the fairest decision for all the teams in the league.
That decision begins with respecting the balance of power, and not allowing a
lower level team to unjustly effect end of year payouts.
What FSRU has done best over the last 5 years
has been listed above in this part of the article. The site has retained team
owners, high quality and experienced team owners. I believe the primary reason
is because of the fair playing field it has provided. New team owners who think
their league fees deserve special consideration, soon realize they will not be
offered any- and some do leave. But the remaining team owners get a unique and
wonderful opportunity to compete against some of the best, on a level playing
field, in a hobby they love.
I hope each of you will join us in the future of this wonderful website.